After reading the online article “Mecca for the rich: Islam's holiest site 'turning into Vegas'” on the Independent website (http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/mecca-for-the-rich-islams-holiest-site-turning-into-vegas-2360114.html ), I realised that many Muslims feel that it is valid for the Saudi’s to remove and destroy the Islamic historic sites in Makkah and Madinah due to the ongoing innovations (Biddah) performed by many pilgrims to these two holy lands.
What is the root cause of Biddah? A lack of education by most pilgrims can be attributed to these novelties. Instead of merely demolishing these traditional sites, which is an easy cop-out for the Saudi’s, hidden under the banner of Wahabism, it may serve the Saudi’s and certainly the Muslim population better to focus more attention and money on education.
A simple suggestion – the Saudi’s can close off all heritage sites and only allow officially endorsed agents to take groups to view the sites. Rules and behaviour must be communicated to pilgrims by the agents. All sites should be protected by tourist police (similar to what is done in Cairo) and if anyone is caught performing Biddah, they should be dealt with appropriately. In this way, education and appreciation for these holy sites will increase and the heritage can still be preserved.
If we don’t start questioning the Saudi’s now, who knows what they would close up next? Imagine having a fence around the Holy Ka’abah. May Allah make it easy for us.
...Me
What is the root cause of Biddah? A lack of education by most pilgrims can be attributed to these novelties. Instead of merely demolishing these traditional sites, which is an easy cop-out for the Saudi’s, hidden under the banner of Wahabism, it may serve the Saudi’s and certainly the Muslim population better to focus more attention and money on education.
A simple suggestion – the Saudi’s can close off all heritage sites and only allow officially endorsed agents to take groups to view the sites. Rules and behaviour must be communicated to pilgrims by the agents. All sites should be protected by tourist police (similar to what is done in Cairo) and if anyone is caught performing Biddah, they should be dealt with appropriately. In this way, education and appreciation for these holy sites will increase and the heritage can still be preserved.
If we don’t start questioning the Saudi’s now, who knows what they would close up next? Imagine having a fence around the Holy Ka’abah. May Allah make it easy for us.
...Me




